A Little White Lie for Sky-High or G-F Black-Bottom Pumpkin Pie

Which one of these is a little white lie:

1. I’m still swimming, it gets easier every day.

2. I didn’t make either of these pies.

3. I made two pies and gave both of them away.

4. I made these pies, ate a slice of both and I swam an extra 50 laps to make up for it.

5. I just had to make the Black-Bottom Pumpkin Pie because it reminded me of my swimsuit.

What? So there was more than one lie, I lied about that too. What’s a little white lie between friends?

When I was volunteering last Friday, Anne remarked that this was absolutely the best pumpkin pie she’d ever tasted. She spoke so longingly and fervently about it, I just had to make one for her so she could enjoy it again.

Then I thought, why not make a Gluten-Free Pumpkin Pie too, because even Gluten-Free people celebrate Thanksgiving. If I had to be honest, those little Stem Ginger Cookies made a better crumb crust.

I think I’m in time for the American Thanksgiving. In Canada, we’re finished with Thanksgiving, we’ve already moved on to Remembrance Day, we’ve started our Christmas shopping and are drinking lattés from Red Starbucks Cups..

Keep up, will you, People!


Sky-High Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin Pie 4

Pumpkin Pie 3



Pumpkin Pie 2

  • Because the pie you made has a very high white layer on top of it – and each molecule contained in that layer is extremely delicious – anything you say is a white lie. As long as it is contained in this post, you understand, right?

    You have absolutely nothing to worry about!

    And that is the pure truth. Sally said so. You better believe it. :-)ReplyCancel

    • What goes in the post, stays in the post.. you are now sworn to the utmost secrecy! Sally said and so it was. That sounds like the start of another post.. xxReplyCancel

  • I couldn’t make two pies that look this good and give both of them away, so that’s my guess ;) I make pumpkin pie with coconut milk, too, (and maple syrup, actually!) and the gingersnap crust sounds killer. And the meringue! And the candied pecans! Oh my goodness! SO yummy.ReplyCancel

  • I don’t think I’ve ever had pumpkin pie with meringue on top! The only kinda black bottom I had better not be talked about…all I can say is, that time I wasn’t responsible for burning food for a change!
    Chocolate and spiced pumpkins and pecans topped with meringue! You forgot to mention it was calorie free! :DReplyCancel

  • Not tempted at all.. What? A lie? How did you guess?ReplyCancel

  • Tessa

    Beautiful pies! Pumpkin pie with meringue? Brilliant! What also caught my eye was that blue bowl with the pecans in it. Lovely!ReplyCancel

  • It’s midnight and I am now sweetly hungry :)ReplyCancel

  • What a pity this one wouldn’t survive an overnight post to the UK. O well, I will have to make my own, but there is no way I’d be giving it away! ReplyCancel

  • I hope you soon love your swimming as much as this pie :)ReplyCancel

  • You may lie as much as necessary in order to get these pies to me ;)

    Choc Chip UruReplyCancel

  • I love the pictures and your writing. That goes without saying. But, I cannot for the life of me understand how anyone could like pumpkin pie:)ReplyCancel

  • Lookin’ dangerous there Barb’ :D – seriously delicious pie, of course :)ReplyCancel

  • I seem to be obsessed by seasons and occasions and I absolutely love the way your blog is so often like a “soundtrack”, but with food, to the changes in the year. Or would that be a “foodtrack”? Lovely! :)ReplyCancel

    • Thanks so much! I do feel influenced by the seasons.. maybe because they’re so much more extreme here. Change of seasons means change of landscape, clothing.. and then the food:) xxReplyCancel

  • Funny! And the pies look great, too. Both true!ReplyCancel

  • Oh my, those pies look A M A Z I N G! And it’s so lovely of you to make one for your friend. I love to bake for my friends too, it just makes me happy. I’m keeping my fingers crossed that you’re still swimming…ReplyCancel

    • I know you do.. that’s why you’ve always got friends over and you make them the most wonderful food:) I’m still swimming! Now everyone here will keep me accountable…ReplyCancel

  • gastrogardener

    I love the idea of meringue on pumpkin pie! My wife makes the pumpkin pies… I’m passing this along!

    Keep swimming!ReplyCancel

  • Kelly @ Inspired Edibles

    Smidge, I saw this meringue pumpkin pie in Chatelaine too and I was drooling!! Your sky-high is even more stunning… truly, what a success. I cannot believe that you would give *both* pies away without duly sampling… so I’m guessing that’s the white bluff ;-).ReplyCancel

    • It was fun to make, I didn’t change a thing.. and went to buy the magazine so I could try a few of the other recipes. It was a good month:) ps I did sampleReplyCancel

  • Pumpkin and pecans with meringue!ReplyCancel

  • hey woman :) now you gotta tell me what gingersnaps crumbs are as this pies do have an amazing crust and I love gluten-free alternative baking. thumb up for this post and recipe.ReplyCancel

  • That Sky High Pumpkin Pie photo belongs on the cover! (of your book, or Just a Smidgen Magazine!) And the pie itself? Well, we know where THAT belongs! (Nooo, not on my thighs! But if that’s the price one has to pay, oh welllll!) (Loved all your little white lies smidge, and of course, x you!) :) xxReplyCancel

    • Some day I ought to put together a book for my kids.. although they’re not as interested in cooking at this stage of their lives;) Nooo.. not the thiiiiggghhhhssss!! xxReplyCancel

  • These pies are gorgeous! That maple one is my favorite. I am so excited for Thanksgiving, we are so desperately trying to keep up..we have the red Starbucks cups, does that count for anything?? ;)ReplyCancel

  • Lies or not .. white or grey – there is no lies in those photos. Wow … I would have loved to have me in my kitchen team. Those indv. Pies I really crave now. Not fair at all, but I have some apple crumble that I will go for now. Barbara, you are Youre the most dangerous temptress there is.ReplyCancel

  • Gorgeous – and nice thinking with the gluten-free option. Please pass a spoon.ReplyCancel

  • Thank you for thinking of those who eat gluten-free, Barbara….my nephew Al loves home-made gluten free stuff. This will be a lovely recipe to try….ReplyCancel

  • This looks incredibly delicious. Love the meringue and the gluten free sounds very intriguing. Once again, beautiful photos and scrumptious recipe.ReplyCancel

  • Oh. My. Goodness. I want nothing to do with either of these. That’s not a white lie….it’s a flat out bold lie! I need these. I need these bad! Smidge, the pictures are gorgeous, and look and sound like everything to be thankful for! You’re amazing.

    Also thankful for those red cups ;)ReplyCancel

  • Those pies look delicious! We don’t really do pumpkin pie in Australia, but after reading so many posts about them, I might just have to give one a go!ReplyCancel

  • I have totally forgotten the exact number but I read somewhere that we all tell quite a few white lies every day! Scary thought. These are drool-worthy recipes. I absolutely love anything with meringue on top. xxReplyCancel

  • What a gorgeous looking pie. I love the image of the slice of pie – it really shows how high that sky-high pie is. And don’t tell me you’ve given up swimming! As my coach used to say to me, ‘You’ve gotta push through the pain barrier’. I hope you give it another try. It’s a fabulous sport that’s easy to fall in love with when you can do it well – and yes, that does take a bit of practise xxReplyCancel

    • I haven’t given up at all.. in fact, I’m starting to quite like it (after only two sessions, lol!). I think it’s the whole “zen” thing about being in the water.. I will keep practicing! Those life guards give out good tips too! xxReplyCancel

  • This is so not fair. I’ve come to accept your extraordinary cake baking & decorating skills, your photographic talent, and your gift with words. Must I add pies to the list, too? I mean, just look at these two beauties! They’re as near to perfection as any pumpkin pie could aspire to be. So not fair.ReplyCancel

    • That Chatelaine recipe was a keeper.. so you can blame them instead of me.. sometimes, it just takes being a good recipe reader/follower of instructions:D Other times, well.. ReplyCancel

  • Suddenly I’m so glad we still have Thanksgiving (and lots of pie!) to look forward to! :)ReplyCancel

  • They look so yummy…I’ve never had success with pumpkin pie but I think it’s psychological ..the very first one I attempted I bought a can of pumpkin pie ….one that my mother used but I never watched her make it I guess and after I was married I poured the contents of the can into a pie crust and baked it!….My poor little brother in law had a piece and his comment was….’sure is pumpkiny’….End of story….DianeReplyCancel

  • A white what, sorry, I am too distracted by your pics of pie to focus on anything else.
    :-) MandyReplyCancel

  • Wow this is so good! I cant stop staring at those yummy photos!ReplyCancel

  • Ha keeping up !! No chance from this side of the pond :)
    I’ll be totally honest – I’ve never made an american/canadian/ or other pumpkin pie. Savoury yes, sweet no.
    With merrangue topping? Uh uh! I just can’t get my head around that one.
    Picked yourself up yet …..
    :) I look at them and think, yup that looks good/gorgeous/amazing…… and then that’s where it stops !
    Now if I was offered a slice of pumpkin pie that would be different…… so I’m on way way round :)ReplyCancel

  • I had my first Starbucks gingerbread latte last week. :) Love this season!!! These pies are beautiful Smidge. The gingerbread cookie crust does sound quite good.ReplyCancel

  • That gluten-free pie looks great!ReplyCancel

  • If you put those 2 pies in front of me, I swear I would not touch them with my fingers. No, it is not a lie, but I will dig into them with my fork.ReplyCancel

  • I like pie but these look amazing! Definitely going to try the Black Bottom! Yum!ReplyCancel

  • You are so right — gluten-free ginger snaps make a wonderful pie crust! Barb, your pies are beautifully done, so very inviting to celebrate. Happy Thanksgiving!ReplyCancel

  • OMG – My pie dreams are real – YUMMERS! Thanks for sharing!ReplyCancel

  • I LOVE pumpkin pie! Nice job!ReplyCancel

  • mjskit

    Both of these pie look delicious but I have to admit that the Black bottom pie really caught my interest. I’d love to taste it so I guess I’ll need to make it. :) Hope you had a wonderful Thanksgiving!ReplyCancel

  • I have never had a pumpkin pie with meringue on top. And the ginger cookie crust sounds even better. These are my types of pies; love them!ReplyCancel

  • Barb, that first photo made my entire mouth fill with saliva! Lie away!!ReplyCancel

  • As always, inspiring and gorgeous!ReplyCancel

  • Coleen Patrick

    I love pumpkin pie, meringue and gluten doesn’t like me–so you’ve just made my day with this recipe! :) YUMReplyCancel

  • Oh goodness! Each one is spectacular! I was hoping one would emerge as the “favorite” but I can’t decide. Maybe I can make one or two now and follow up with Christmas! Pumpkin is a favorite in my family year-round. My son-in-law even asked for a pumpkin pie for his October birthday, and gingersnaps are my dad’s favorite cookie, so I think I must commit! I don’t know that I will ever bake as beautifully as you do, Barbara, but the recipes are so lovely I know they will taste good…and I don’t have to take photographs of my end result! :-)ReplyCancel

  • Aaaah, that explains it! Canada is why us folks south of the border see Christmas decorations everywhere before Halloween even hits! Hehehe, just kidding :). The pies look fantastic, Smidge, especially the one with all that fluffy meringue!ReplyCancel

  • It would never have occurred to me to put meringue on a pumpkin pie – it looks so lovely! Both pies sound and look so good, but I know I’ll never be able to serve one at Thanksgiving. That’s because my daughter the Tradition Enforcer is adamant that old recipes not be adjusted in any way when it comes to the apparently sacred menu for this holiday. On the other hand, I could make one of these pies any other time that I want!ReplyCancel

  • Oh my gosh that meringue is beautiful. Even though we haven’t had Thanksgiving here in America yet, I’ve already started my shopping, and even listened to some Christmas music this week. :-)ReplyCancel

  • Thats the prettiest pie so far today and in general I believe. Number 4 is for sure a lie, right? =P
    Just looking at your pie makes me feel guilty and I have a feeling I gained a couple of cages by the minute. lol I d love to make it, so thank you for sharing it with us, its the right and only decision.ReplyCancel

  • These both look fantastic! I love the idea of meringue on a pumpkin pie. I may suggest that for this year’s Thanksgiving!ReplyCancel

  • You ARE in time for Thanksgiving! I love everything about BOTH of these pies! But I can’t keep up… my neighbors have put up Christmas lights and its got me all out of sorts. Not yet!! Thanks for visiting me at Carol Anne’s page– your site is gorgeous; I might be lost here for days! My gravatar’s not linking back properly… I’m at http://www.sugardishme.com. Thanks for the gingersnappy twist!ReplyCancel

  • I’m don’t which to choose – lies or pies! Let me just say I love the sound of the crust – I think I just might have to give it a try.ReplyCancel

  • Drat. I shouldn’t have read this – now I’m going to have to go to the shop and pick up a tasty treat..ReplyCancel

  • This looks over the top delicious Smidge! I think I’m going to have to make this one. Yum! And Gluten free too! My youngest is gluten free. I should be but with my line of work it’s not always possible.ReplyCancel

  • Wow you have been busy.:)ReplyCancel

  • I love meringue on any pie – these look divine!ReplyCancel

  • Pumpkin and pecan?! Sounds like the perfect combination!ReplyCancel

  • I am looking for gluten free recipes for my family and ran across this. Wow. This looks so good. I limit my goodies, but I will have to try this.ReplyCancel

Your email is never published or shared.