I quickly popped into Williams Sonoma on a Saturday evening around 5:30 pm to pick up a bag of my favorite gluten free Cup4Cup flour and was shocked at the large volume of people still shopping. We seem to have become an insatiable society of consumers looking for the next big score on their hunt for a deal. Streams of jostling humans make their journey to shopping mecca and pay homage to their retail gods every single day. What used to be an occasional indulgence has become a year-round (and sometimes the only) hobby for many. Scores of people are shopping for the feel-good rush of a new trendy purse or pair of shoes.. all wrapped up in pretty ribbons and bags. We are seduced by the marketing that tells us these will give us confidence, a happier life… even an improved self-image.
There are books about overindulging our children, but what about the example we set for them?
â¥
I’ve begun to question my own love for shopping. I grew up in a home where my brothers and I owned two pairs of shoes (one for summer and one for winter), one pair of runners and one pair of winter boots. While I do love shopping for clothes or a new pair of shoes like the next person, I wonder about the addictive nature of marketing, our response to it and I’ve noticed how fleeting that “feel good” response is after purchasing. After only a few days, that new outfit hangs in my closet and is not so special any more.
Personally, I feel that I’m a complete sucker for the whole shopping experience. Let me stroll through any organic grocery store, Whole Foods for instance, and I’m in love with the beautifully displayed produce. The atmosphere just makes me feel “special” as a customer and I enjoy the taking my time while perusing their aisles.
â¥
If these pleasures are so ephemeral, I wondered, what pursuits give long lasting pleasure and fulfillment, even self-confidence? I believe that those pleasures are so entirely simple and sustainable for me. My family, my friends, my creative pursuits, and my health/fitness. It’s that simple. Occasional travel, while being completely fantastic, is not a “fundamental” necessity for me to enjoy my life in a simple day-to-day way, it’s just a nice treat once in a while.
I do love being surrounded by beauty, whether in my garden or by the simple rearranging of furniture and decor accessories.. a simple bouquet of flowers. I love the peace and the reflection that comes with time alone yet I am revived with the laughter that comes from the companionship of friends and family. It’s all about balance.
It is these simple pleasures that I’d like to focus on for 2014.
â¥
In order to achieve my goal of living more frugally, I decided to analyze my current grocery shopping habits. If people can thrift for vintage clothing and home goods, why not be thrifty when buying food… Food Thrifting! Not a bad idea for a food blogger!
I have shopped almost exclusively at Safeway for convenience and have my Safeway discount card. I frequent Sunterra and Blush Lane for produce or specialty items that aren’t carried at Safeway. On weekends I’ll drive to our Farmer’s Market for the sweetest carrots and fresh fruit when it’s in season. In fact, I used to go to most of these shops to source the “best of the best” produce available.
For the past few weeks I’ve price checked items at both Walmart and Safeway and kept a spreadsheet for comparison. It really isn’t a surprise that prices are substantially lower at Walmart, I expected that. I just wondered how much lower. Here is my spreadsheet, while by no means extensive, all items are identical and would be products I purchase. Where offered, I used the Safeway Cardholder discounted prices.
â¥
Walmart is 16% cheaper than Safeway and the total difference was $56.34.
But what about atmosphere and customer service? Safeway definitely has better product display, quicker lineups and is visually much cleaner and more appealing. Staff at Safeway are very helpful and congenial. Walmart staff go out of their way to chat with you when you enter the store and when you check out, but don’t visit Walmart on a Sunday at the end of a holiday or you could be waiting in line for hours.
Some produce at Walmart is substandard (the grey, shrivelled raspberries would be inedible) yet other produce was totally fine and comparable to Safeway. Walmart has a McDonalds (not a place where I’d eat, although I hear their coffee is excellent) and Safeway has Starbucks or Tim Hortons. What I really appreciate about Walmart is not having to dig through my purse for a stupid quarter or dollar to get a shopping cart. Having said that, Walmart needs to hire staff that can bring the carts back into the store during busier hours. Safeway has Air Miles and many people travel using those points. I’m not one to bother clipping coupons, but I’d be interested to know if this makes a huge difference for Canadian shoppers.
I’ve never been one to price check, but now that I have, I really can’t stand paying so much more for the identical product. But days can get busy and on those days, the store that gets my hard-earned buck will almost always be the store closest to home.
So here’s the plan.. on days when I can plan ahead, I will hit Walmart or Superstore first for dry goods, then pick up what’s missing next door at Safeway. But let me be clear.. I also love to shop local and support our Alberta artisan bakers, farmers and meat producers.. so when I have time, I’ll be making trips to the Farmer’s Market, etc on weekends. Nothing beats the quality and taste of produce grown locally.
I also understand economies of scale, I get that we should shop Canadian when we can. It just seems prices on dry goods is almost arbitrarily marked up. For instance, why would Terra Chips cost $3.97 at Walmart and $6.59 at Safeway? I have also heard that most stores have Loss Leaders where a few popular items are drastically reduced to draw in customers, who then go on to purchase the rest of their groceries in that store.
Superstore and Costco have the added benefit of a more extensive line of cheeses, deli products, etc. I have heard that prescriptions are less expensive at Superstore and will have to confirm. I have heard the meat at Costco and the seafood at Superstore are both excellent, but so much of this is personal taste. When I can, I like to pick up my meat, poultry, wild game etc at Rocky Mountain Game Meats. They will have your order ready and vacuum packed in the quantities you request. Their product is outstanding.
I have also heard quality of on-the-job experience for staff and wages vary greatly between stores, I have no knowledge of this but hope it’s not the case.
Update: This just in from CBC Radio Show “The Current”: Minimum Wage Wars: Walmart Canada.
Update: Just this evening, this CBC Radio Show aired: “The Current” Minimum Wage Wars: Earning Below the Poverty Line.
â¥
Most surprisingly, through changing my grocery shopping habits.. I’ve discovered that there is something quite satisfying about being thrifty and this is a change that, so far, has been more lasting than any impulse shopping I have ever done.
Next up.. I think I should compare Brand Name products with “No Name” brands.. what do you think?
â¥
Update: Today at Safeway I saw a gal with a bar code reader plugged right into her computer. She was walking through the aisles zapping everything and it went straight into her cart. I certainly did things the old fashioned way!
Very interesting post Barb and I agree so much with how you feel about so many of us seeking happiness through shopping. I am one who loves to browse the gourmet food stores, William Sonoma – I could spend hours in there! It’s amazing tho, since I’ve been unemployed since October, I stopped clothes shopping and have been surprised with all the outfits I’m putting together from my very own closet! Imagine that! For groceries I have a small Italian market that sells fresh, local fruits and veggies at great prices. So I stick to what is available and do without the rest!
I do the same now, Linda! I’m shopping my own closet to come up with new outfits and remembering how much I loved those pieces when I first bought them, lol! I think you have the best solution, buy local and in season!
Being thrifty is good, but not at the expense of all the little shops and then indirectly whole neighbourhoods. I’ve read a considerable amount on Walmart in the USA and seen towns there that have died as a result of a nearby superstore.
Buying fresh seasonal fish, fruit, meat and vegetables from local sources protects the local economy and provides the freshest food. Some of the food from supermarkets can be several years old before it ends up in your basket, including “fresh” fruit and vegetables.
I totally agree, our city is so large it can support a number of stores, thankfully! And we have a thriving local farmer’s market every weekend that I love to visit! It’s sad that big box stores can shut down a whole town! I think the idea of years old food just sounds nasty!!
…and that year old plus “fresh” food can still look like it was picked yesterday! So you’d never know.
Barbara this was a very interesting post, and I am curious to see the feedback you will have. It is hard to comment on this, because the subject is complex, there are many sides and perspectives, I could probably fill pages and pages.. we don’t want that, do we? 😉
To make it short: some of my friends here in the US make a point of never setting foot on Wal Mart, for many reasons, mostly related to the way they treat their employees. I have mixed feelings about it all – part of me feels that because I can afford to shop in other places (including Mom and Pop stores around town), I should not give my money to Wal Mart. However, when I interact with the folks who clean our floors in the lab, who keep the buildings safe, who take care of our garbage and gardens, I am forced to admit that without places like Wal Mart to shop, they would be in real trouble. Who am I to advise them to boycott WM? What can I offer them in its place?
(I hope I did not “speak” too much… 🙂
Haha, I don’t mind your pages and pages Sally! I would like to hear more about the treatment of their employees, that’s just not right. I don’t watch a lot of television, so maybe there have been shows about this. It’s such a complicated issue.. if no one shopped at Walmart those people would then be unemployed. I think everyone should find a plan that suits their own budget.. and if it is within their means.. shop local first. To further complicate things, there’s the issue of trying to eat organic. I always think I’d love to live in a small town that has local “everything”.. then I could walk out the door and shop in each little store for only those ingredients I need for the day. Sigh.. a girl can dream!
Unfortunately we just don’t have enough competition in Australia for the prices to be that different. I’m a little bit anti the big supermarkets (grocery stores) here because they’re not very nice to their suppliers but I agree, frugal is good.
We get a fortnightly delivery of a box of in-season organic fruit and vege and I do a big online shop for staples every 2-3 weeks then top up at our local small grocery store. I love hearing how other people do their food shopping.
It’s interesting, I’ve just begun reading about the issues with treatment of suppliers. If what I read is correct, they try to force the supplier to sell for less so they can turn around and sell for less? I’ve thought about getting an organic food delivery, thanks for reminding me about that, Claire. What online resource do you use for staples?
A huge difference in price for the same products. I don’t understand why in some areas of the country we don’t have the competitive pricing. Here in Greenville, SC for the most part all of the grocery stores compete for business, BI-LO, Publix, Ingles, Food City and Walmart. A few stores like Whole Foods, Trader Joes,they don’t even try to compete. Walmart is now building Walmart Grocery stores (groceries only) all around Greenville. Shopping at Walmart gives me a headache! As long as Publix, Ingles or BI-LO has the same pricing at Walmart, I avoid Walmart. Walmart in our area does not have good cold-cut or meats.
The price differences was inconsistent, that’s what makes me wonder about all of this. Normally I wouldn’t care, but my own food bill rose considerably in the last year. Our Safeway chain was bought out by Sobey’s so many were worried about diminishing competition. But my gosh, we have seven grocery stores in my neighborhood, all within a 10 minute drive. I wonder how they all survive. I will say.. shopping at Walmart is everything I dislike about shopping! It also requires a second stop for everything they don’t have, like cold-cuts and decent veggies etc. As I mentioned to Sally, I wish I lived in Europe where you walk down the street and stop in and shop at specialty stores for your food each day, wouldn’t that be a great lifestyle?
I am definitely a sucker for convenience and know that I paid way too much for that cantaloupe today! I have heard Safeway classifies their stores. Stores with a Grade A classification receive the best produce. Those stores are typically located in more affluent neighbourhoods. Lower graded stores receive a lesser quality of produce. I am curious to know if their pricing of goods and produce is comparable between all stores or priced depending on the store’s classification.
I knew there were Grades for clothing stores, now to find out the same is for food just drives me crazy. I’ll have to take my list down to another store and just see the difference in a few items. My brother just told me Superstore has a program that gives you money back with a rewards card.. to buy more groceries in their store. I’ll have to check out their prices as well. (p.s. nice to see you today:D!!)
Very interesting post, Barb. I HATE shopping at WalMart for anything – just entering the store overwhelms me with awful consumer guilt. We buy all our dry goods at Superstore, because you’re right – the price difference is just too hard to pass up on (which is pretty hypocritical of me considering my feelings about WalMart). We are lucky to be able to buy all our meats from the local meat market and fresh produce from the local green grocer. I’m always reminded of something that someone once told my mum: grocery shopping is a political act, meaning that every dollar you spend is a vote for what you spend it on. I try to keep that in mind when I can and buy local and organic first when available/affordable. But it’s a juggle, and it’s definitely not black and white or even possible for everyone. It just goes to show how complicated our food systems really are. Some really great responses here too – you’ve started a good discussion!
I think your mom is right, it’s a political act for sure.. In my perfect world, everyone could afford and would be able to buy local, fresh, and organic. Stores would pay above minimum wage.. and employees would be lifted out of poverty. I bet almost all grocery stores pay minimum or barely above.. and I bet the same would be said about most retail shops too. It is so complicated, isn’t it? Thanks for sharing your ideas, Korena!
When you look at some of the differences… it really is startling… my husband goes through all the flyers to find out products that we buy consistently… but we don’t drive out of the way far or we end up spending more in gas… Costco is really good for some things but we don’t do a lot there as you have to buy in such large quantities. …. hint … if you like stew we find they have amazing stewing beef … and we just divide it into 2 or 3 packages and freeze… I think you should do the name vs no name…. if you’re up for it… Diane
Really interesting post. I saw a study someone in Austin, Texas did a few years ago comparing produce from Walmart, Whole Foods, and a few other places. They bought the produce and gave it to a restaurant chef to prepare. The Walmart stuff scored pretty well. I’ve shopped at a Walmart Super Store in the past, and I found the produce to be quite good. A large selection(in part because their customer base is so diverse), and the rest of the groceries they offer are certainly competitively priced. But it’s a more limited selection than at most supermarkets, and the whole shopping experience there is kind of soul-sucking. Their checkout is beyond bad, or at least it was back when I shopped there (this is probably 6 or so years ago). I gave up on them after a few months – if you shop the specials at the supermarket, you can usually do as well. Usually. 😉
Well, now I did make a salad with their produce and truthfully, it wasn’t bad at all. Like any store, we have to select produce that looks great. Costco has some awesome fruit most of the time. But.. yes.. I, too, find it soul-sucking.. Walmart should hire a food blogger like us, I know we could make it awesome with so few changes!!
The first thing I read that surprised me was that it sounds as if you have to pay to use a cart at the market – is that true? I can see where that would encourage people to bring their own bags but I’m surprised since I’d guess people buy less toting bags rather than overfilling a cart.
I used to be a buyer in retailing although not food related. The rule of thumb is to have loss leaders (you lose a little to bring people in the store). Most stores will then price competitively on highly recognizable items & you’d better be priced right on those. After that, you have to come up with a mix of “meet, beat, and beef up the profits” by meeting your competition, beating them on some, and averaging out your profits on with marking up the rest. Usually the highest markups will be on impulse items (watch out for the check out counter items). Price shopping is a good thing to do and it all depends on the typical items you buy plus deciding if it’s worth the gas to travel to a different store. We’re lucky right now in Massachusetts since we’ve had a lot of really great grocery stores come into the area – prices are very competitive and the selection is great.
Glad you started this discussion, personally I do not shop at Walmart. As far as produce goes I am self-sufficient from my own garden. Other items I try to buy from local stores near me as the sales taxes generated from those sales benefit my community.
I’m joining a food buying club to get more things in bulk- organic flour, sugar, butter, paper products, supplements and things like that.
I’m also trying not to buy double which I’ve done due to not cleaning the pantry- that’s downright silly.
Great post … I shop a lot on “low cost” shops. Excellent value for the money and I could shop a lot more – my supermarket is just close by and the other low cost shop are a bit far away.
You have done a brilliant job with this and it shows very clearly how much money there is to be saved. I personal couldn’t care about the atmosphere in a shop if it saves me money. Fancy shelving doesn’t put food on my table.
I just can’t get my head around buy food at Walmart. I definitely would never include them in my regular shopping. Did you hear that Sobeys contacted all their suppliers and asked for a price reduction? Should be interesting to see how that plays out. I’m a Co-op shopper, with other stores filling in for convenience or when I can’t find something. I think the biggest saving for me is planning and not throwing things out!
I think there’s differences between Walmarts as well.. the one by my parents and down south by Costco are much more pleasant to shop at. That’s interesting that Sobey’s is doing that, they were always so much more expensive than Safeway. I guess they have more buying power now that they’ve bought Safeway. I’ve heard Co-op has a great meat department and a great selection of organic veggies and fruit. But, yes, not throwing food out is a huge step towards being frugal!
Hey Barb- lovely lovely post! I also grew up as a kid who had enough, but never TOO much. And I began over-indulging only once I became financially independent. I feel the same way- I can get carried away even in a grocery store, buying botand often a top which I thought was a great buy gets boring after one wear or two. I loved this line “If these pleasures are so ephemeral, I wondered, what pursuits give long lasting pleasure and fulfillment, even self-confidence?” I’m also going to try and focus on the simpler pleasures this year!
Barb, this was a great piece, thank you! I’ve linked back to it in my latest post! xx
I’ve just read yours.. I’m so glad I inspired you to make even more suggestions for being frugal! Now if only I could have a garden like yours. If we’re home more this summer, I will have a go at it! xx
G’day! Really enjoyed reading your blog post today as highlighted by Celia, true!
Great reminder as there is always something people worldwide can do to save money and live within their means, improving their quality of life too!
Cheers! Joanne
Thanks, Joanne.. I really enjoyed reading Celia’s ideas as well. There’s so much food for thought there, no pun intended. I hope some day I can have a garden as amazing as hers. Just think how wonderful my recipes would taste! And I’ve got to get on the bread baking as well.. after all, if I follow her recipes I’ve got it made, right:)
[…] all know I’ve been investigating grocery store chain food pricing.. well wait ’til you read […]
And I think Safeway first has to make sure it competes with indirect rivals like Wal-Mart and Costco. And it shouldn’t take a risky step of market development at this stage. They should make sure firs that they penetrate in the US market. And when they saturate this market, then they should go for market development http://bit.ly/QNSdp6